asher63 (asher63) wrote,
asher63
asher63

'Two Scholars Who Were in Our Town' by S. Y. Agnon - book notes

For a short while (sections 15-18) it looks as if Moshe Pinchas is experiencing some remorse for his vindictive attitude towards Shlomo. But, as he confides to his mother, he is not entirely his own master. Perhaps the Almighty is "hardening his heart" as with Pharaoh. Or maybe his pride prevents him from accepting kindness or forgiveness from Shlomo. Maybe Shlomo himself, subconsciously, contributes to this? It's almost as if he feels he has to shame Moshe Pinchas into repentance, while proving himself to be the "bigger man". (For one thing, offering Moshe Pinchas the rabbinic post would have placed him forever in Shlomo's debt.) See Avot 4:18. Sometimes I think there's such a thing as being too good, too kind, too forgiving; it starts to look as if you are trying to subtly humiliate the other party. You have to forgive, but you also have to show that you're human too.
Tags: agnon, books, hebrew
Subscribe

  • Genesis 13: Seeing the land.

    GENESIS 13: SEEING THE LAND. Abram and Lot ascend from Egypt, returning to the southern part of the Land of Israel, the Negev. Strife breaks out…

  • Genesis 12: Go forth.

    GENESIS 12: GO FORTH. The third section in the traditional annual cycle of Torah readings begins here, with G-d's summons to Avram. The early…

  • Genesis 11: From Noah to Abram.

    GENESIS 11: FROM NOAH TO ABRAM The early history of man closes with a list of the generations after Noah (or more precisely, the descendants of…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments