asher63 (asher63) wrote,
asher63
asher63

A Jewish reading of 'Game of Thrones'.

My friend Professor Michael Weingrad weighs in on GoT:

And it’s not only politics that Martin treats with bracing realism. His books are shorn of much of our present-day, feel-good notions about the goodness of human nature, the malleability of gender, and other contemporary dogmas. The idealizations he avoids are less chivalric than progressive ones.

At their most compelling, the books and the television series offer characters who see the world and themselves through commitments to family, clan, and nation, rather than our narrow, present-day lens of atomized individuals and their arbitrary desires. “Everything I did, I did for my house and my family,” says Jamie Lannister, an admission echoed at one time or another by most of the show’s characters.

The evident fascination of so many readers and viewers with such thick social connections is worth noting. I happen to live in Portland, surrounded by people indifferent if not hostile to tradition, people who want to live their lives independently of family, religion, canons of art and literature, nationhood, biology, market behavior, and probably the laws of physics. Yet many of them are deeply invested in the continuity of House Stark and House Targaryen.

Of course, such fantasies also feature characters who rebel against their societal roles, and that too is part of the attraction. ...

Unfortunately, the writers of the HBO series seem in the end to have been unable to sympathize with the possibility of a positive identity not reducible to a 21st-century self. This imaginative failure sounded ever louder in the characters’ speech, as when Arya Stark, rejecting her courtly role, explains “It’s not me,” or when Danaerys’s advisors repeatedly proclaim their desire to “make the world a better place” and to “leave the world a little better than we found it.” (Given that the show runners are both Jewish, I was relieved that none of the characters mentioned “tikkun olam,” but it was surely a close thing.) The Starbucks cup inadvertently left on a feasting table in one scene was widely reported as a gaffe, but it wasn’t out of place with the show’s contemporary ethos at that point.

You are hereby invited to go read the whole thing at the link, to find out what Prof. Weingrad considers to be real knowledge, and why it matters in the Shavu'oth season.
Tags: entertainment, grrm, hebraica
Subscribe

  • Gilad - Sema Milele.

    Via my friend Yehudah Kimani in Kenya. (Yehudah is not related to Wendy Kimani.)

  • Nigeria's Jewish community.

    From i24 News, via Arutz Sheva.

  • Hope.

    "Hatikva" sung by children at Magen Avraham Synagogue, Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria. Via Yomtov Shmuel Okuma. Facebook post This is in a…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 4 comments